Monday, May 11, 2009

More Omen of the Stars Theories

Warning, Spoilers for Sunrise!

I just had a theory idea! In an author chat, Vicky (one of the Erins,) said that there would soon be an evil female character. When Hollyleaf turned bad, fans assumed that this was the female evil cat that Vicky was talking about. But there have been theories surfacing that either Ivykit or Dovekit could turn evil or twisted.

The description of The Fourth Apprentice states, "Soon one sister will have an ominous dream-and will soon realize she has mythical skills unmatched by any other cat." [About Ivykit and Dovekit]

Hmm...sounds like one sister will be getting magical skills possessed by the 'Three.' Could the other sister become jealous and follow Hollyleaf's footsteps? (Pawsteps?) Could the same ungifted sister choose to follow Tigerstar? After all, its been ages since we've had a real 'villain.'

Perhaps the other sister dies, releasing the full potential of the gifted sister's abilities. Maybe the ungifted sister is meant to be another Feathertail.

It seems unlikely that Erin will just let that other ungifted sister fade into the background. I think that there will be as much focus on the gifted sister as well as the ungifted sister.

-Sorrelpaw
What are YOUR thoughts?

9 comments:

Emily Ravinsky said...

I think that Dovekit will die, not be killed since they will be apprentices and not warriors like Tigerstar. But I think overall that the "power of three" kit will be Ivykit.

★ Sylvine Srevlis ★ said...

Dovekit is on the cover of the first book in the next series, and Ivykit is on the next. I think that they both will have some sort of prophecy about them.

I have an idea; what if neither of them was chosen by StarClan at birth, but later StarClan would choose between them?


~~Silverstar

Camila/Dawncloud said...

Ok, so the kin of your kin would be your grandkids, right? Because Firestar would be Ivykit's and Dovekit's great grandfather. Basically, I'm confused. Sorry!

☪Dream said...

Newpath

I have heard that in the fourth prophecy the first book Firestar will die.Then Bramleclaw won't full fill Firestar.So Brambleclaw will not be leader.I personally think Firestar will not die because he has quite a few lives left.Unless they get ripped from him like Scourge did to Tigerstar.I really don't know.But Firesatr was so awesome in the first prophecy!!!Then in the second prophecy i liked Squirrelflight.In the third prophecy my favourite was Jayfeather!!!I have made my own warrior clan.There is a leader,kits,apprentices,queens,warriors and medicine cats.One more thing i think dovekit will be the fourth apprentice.

☪Dream said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Anonymous said...

I agree with Cami.

So perhaps ....
Hollyleaf is going to show up.

Because Ivykit and Dovekit will be the kin of his kin of his kin(right?).

eleanor mcgrath said...

hollyleaf won't come back and i don't think either sister will turn evil. it could be someone else. it doesn't even have to be in thunderclan.

Rainmask said...

Well i personally dont thik Firestar will die!!! Dovekit is probably the other Prophecy cat, I think.

Jayfeather314 said...

hey guys here r some spoilers!
dovekit is the third cat and becomes dovepaw who is an apprentice to lionblaze and in sign of the moon she becomes dovewing and ivypool.
when ivypool was an apprentice she gets trained by the dark forest and turns slightly evil but dont worry she becomes good and then is a spy for the three because they told her about the prophecy.And firestar dosent die well not yet.And Jayfeather and a couple of other cats go to the mountains in sign of the moon and brook and stormfur have kits but i wont tell you their names because you read that for yourself.Sorry if i just spoiled it for you but i am so excited. if you want any more info visit my blog(just click on my name)and i will answer your questions if i can!