Warning, Spoilers for Sunrise...
"What if Pinestar was Firestars father. It would explain why he felt drawn to the forest but of course thats just a theory."
Wow...that would mean Firestar, Scourge and Tigerstar are half-brothers. That would be an interesting twist! But...there is a rather large hole in this theory. Cinderpelt's prophecy. Remember how she saw tiger in fire? It meant the kin of Firestar and Tigerstar would be strong enough to rule the forest. (this was then followed by the three kin of your kin prophecy.) That would kind of be a mess...don't you think?
Squirrelflight and Brambleclaw would be related. Ew? That wouldn't really matter much though since Crowfeather and Leafpool are the parents of Jay, Lion and Holly.
It would be cool if Firestar and Tigerstar were half-brothers but I doubt it. :( However, you never know with the Erins! Ryan, you may see this theory come true one day. Keep a close eye on the upcoming books, perhaps the Erins will let something slip!
Keep up those awesome theories!
-Sorrelpaw
12 comments:
Wait but Owlstar was the leader before Sunstar and before that was Thunderstar. In Secrets of the Clans it doesn't have anything about Pinestar. Where did you get this news?
-Sandpaw/Sandbreeze/Sandstar (of CrystalClan)
Hmm, and another thing... Is Pinestar ginger-colored, do you know? Because he would have to be ginger-colored to be Firestar's father. But even though that is and interesting theory, I agree that it's pretty impossible.
And Sandstar, I think that Owlstar was the second leader of ThunderClan EVER. In Secrets of the Clans they have a huge gap where there were other leaders.
~~Silverstar
Thanks for posting my comment sorrel paw. But how could firestar and sourge be half brothers am i missing anything in he story here
yeah floppyj10, they said that they posted the MOST important leaders and medicine cats. obviously pinestar wasn't that important. i love the theory
In The Rise of Scourge, Scourge's mother mentioned his father having ginger-colored fur. The authors later confirmed that Firestar and Scourge had the same father, but different mothers. It is also possible that their father WAS a Clan cat, or a rouge. But it's pretty impossible that Firestar and Tigerstar could be that closely related.
~~Silverstar
Hey Sorrelpaw, go to www.cookieandmore.blogspot.com for a special surprise!
~~Silverstar
Ok, now I'm dizzy, but I think this one might be true.
That would be interesting. . . .
But another thing with Sunrise, i cant beleive hollyleaf is dead!
I think that theory is awsome!
Scorges dad was ginger coloured and pinestar was reddish brown..
in code of the clans lionpaw found out that pinestar was visiting with 2legs... & in blustars quest pinestar leaves... so he was like ginger, if not age could have done it so he mates with tiny & rustys mom & then dies
or he runs away and then dies of old age!!!
Post a Comment